The Best Burger in NYC: 12 Jaw-Dropping Patties You’ll Dream About Tonight

Discover the 12 best burgers in NYC—from iconic cheeseburgers to secret smash patties. Warning: extreme cravings ahead.

Let’s get something straight: a burger isn’t just a meal. In New York City, it’s a cultural moment. A rite of passage. A full-on religious experience sandwiched between a toasted bun. Whether you’re a ketchup minimalist or a double-stack maximalist, the city that never sleeps has a burger that’ll knock your tastebuds into next week.

But where exactly do you find the best burger in NYC? That’s what this guide is for. We’ve scoured every borough, queued at cult joints, argued with cab drivers, and risked mustard stains on vintage tees—all in pursuit of burger glory.

So grab a napkin, cancel your salad order, and let’s dive in.

---

🍔 1. Emily (West Village) — The Emmy Burger

Why it slaps: Dry-aged beef, caramelized onions, pretzel bun, secret Emmy sauce, and that signature dry-aged funk? This isn’t a burger. It’s a personality.

Vibe: Rustic wood tables, hip-hop beats, and the faint aroma of wood-fired pizza in the air.

Instagram moment: That pretzel bun sheen. Drool.

Burger verdict: $28 never tasted so worth it.

---

🍔 2. 7th Street Burger (East Village + multiple locations)

Why it slaps: No frills. No reservations. Just a double-patty smashburger that looks like it’s about to fight you. And you’ll let it.

Vibe: Late-night cravings. Neon lights. Greasy wrappers.

Instagram moment: Gooey cheese waterfall as you rip it in half.

Burger verdict: Best greasy bodega energy burger you’ll ever love.

---

🍔 3. Minetta Tavern (Greenwich Village) — The Black Label Burger

Why it slaps: Dry-aged prime beef blend from Pat LaFrieda. You’re not just eating a burger—you’re eating status.

Vibe: Old New York. Candlelight. Literary ghosts whispering about Hemingway’s cholesterol.

Instagram moment: That cross-section of pink medium-rare perfection.

Burger verdict: Sophisticated. Expensive. Worth your last $38.

---

🍔 4. Au Cheval (Tribeca)

Why it slaps: It’s technically a “cheeseburger,” but that’s like calling Beyoncé just a singer. Thick, juicy patties, melty cheese, Dijonnaise, and a fried egg if you’re bold.

Vibe: Moody lighting, leather booths, whiskey on the rocks.

Instagram moment: The fried egg drip. You’ll know it when you see it.

Burger verdict: Indulgent. Over-the-top. Addictive.

---

🍔 5. Corner Bistro (West Village)

Why it slaps: Classic NYC. No gimmicks. Just an old-school bar burger with a side of nostalgia.

Vibe: Dive bar energy. Cheap beer. Locals only.

Instagram moment: It’s not pretty, but it’s proud. Embrace the grit.

Burger verdict: The best $10 burger this side of 6th Avenue.

---

🍔 6. J.G. Melon (Upper East Side)

Why it slaps: It’s a cheeseburger with a cult following. Grilled onions optional, but if you skip them, we can’t be friends.

Vibe: Green-checkered tablecloths, cramped booths, UES royalty.

Instagram moment: That classic American diner burger shot.

Burger verdict: Consistent since forever. That’s a flex.

---

🍔 7. Shake Shack (Madison Square Park + many more)

Why it slaps: It’s fast food, but make it gourmet. The ShackBurger is the gateway drug to NYC burger obsession.

Vibe: Outdoor tables. Lines. Always lines.

Instagram moment: That perfect branded wrapper peek.

Burger verdict: The people’s cheeseburger. Ubiquitous—and still crushes.

---

🍔 8. Raoul’s (SoHo) — The Off-Menu Burger

Why it slaps: Only 12 a night. Topped with Saint-André cheese and served with au poivre sauce. Classy, rare, and unforgettable.

Vibe: French bistro meets NYC cool.

Instagram moment: Candlelight + mystery burger = date night flex.

Burger verdict: If you know, you know.

---

🍔 9. Burger Joint (Hidden inside Le Parker Meridien)

Why it slaps: Secret spot behind velvet curtains. No branding. Just a greasy burger worth the adventure.

Vibe: Dive bar energy meets hotel chic.

Instagram moment: Neon sign + graffiti walls + iconic burger wrap.

Burger verdict: Secret menu legend status.

---

🍔 10. Red Hook Tavern (Brooklyn)

Why it slaps: Dry-aged beef, American cheese, house-made pickles, potato bun. A Brooklyn masterpiece.

Vibe: Laid-back cool. Feels like your foodie friend’s kitchen.

Instagram moment: Cross-section + sunlight from the bar window.

Burger verdict: Outer borough supremacy.

---

🍔 11. Smash’d NYC (Food truck / pop-ups)

Why it slaps: Street smashburgers done right. Crispy edges, juicy insides, and spontaneous locations.

Vibe: Find them on Instagram. Follow the meat.

Instagram moment: Burger + skyline = viral gold.

Burger verdict: The best burger you didn’t plan for.

---

🍔 12. Paul’s Da Burger Joint (East Village)

Why it slaps: It’s chaos. It’s messy. It’s unapologetically huge. This is where calorie counting goes to die.

Vibe: Retro-diner realness. Red vinyl booths. Zero pretense.

Instagram moment: You vs. the burger she told you not to worry about.

Burger verdict: Hangover cure approved.

---

What Makes a Burger “The Best” in NYC?

Let’s not pretend this is science—it’s more like alchemy. A NYC burger must:

• Be made with high-quality beef (ideally Pat LaFrieda if you’re fancy)
• Have a balanced bun-to-meat-to-cheese ratio
• Offer crave-inducing simplicity or mind-blowing creativity (nothing in-between)
• Be photogenic enough to pause your bite for a pic—but not for long
• Hold its own at 2PM or 2AM

Whether you’re into smashburgers, towering stacks, or bougie brioche buns, the best burger in NYC hits your soul as much as your stomach.

---

Burger Tips for Foodies on the Hunt

• Don’t fear the line: If they’re lined up outside in January? That burger’s fire.
• Medium-rare is king: Stop overcooking your dreams.
• Follow your gut (and your Instagram feed): NYC burger trends shift fast. Keep up.
• Two hands, no shame: Drips, stains, and grease glistens are part of the rite.

---

So there it is. The meaty truth. From high-end to hole-in-the-wall, this list is your golden map to the burger gods of New York City.

Will everyone agree? Absolutely not.

That’s the point.

The best burger in NYC is personal. It’s visceral. It’s unforgettable. And if you’re reading this while hungry—our work here is done.

So next time someone says, “You have to try this place,” you’ll have 12 reasons to one-up them.